Netflix Original My Oxford Year: Sofia Carson’s Romantic Comedy with an Age-Old Trope

Drawing buzz as a recently released romantic comedy, ‘My Oxford Year’ is gaining momentum among cinephiles. Premiering on August 1, 2025, this Netflix original blends emotion and wit in a contemporary setting. This marks another notable addition to Sofia Carson’s growing filmography, this time with co-star Corey Mylchreest. Let's uncover how its story and cast performance justify the anticipation.

The Team Behind the Scenes and On-screen Cast

Melissa Osborne and Allison Burnett wrote this romantic drama. It draws inspiration from Julia Whelan’s novel of the same name, itself a reimagining of Burnett’s original screenplay.

This Temple Hill Entertainment production excels with Iain Morris as its director.

Besides Carson and Mylchreest, the ensemble cast includes Catherine McCormack and Dougray Scott.

My Oxford Year (2025) Review

.

Story: Main Theme and Subplot

The story unfolds with ease, simple, steady, and sincere, but it rarely strays from the familiar. At its core, it's about Anna, a determined young American chasing her long-held dream of studying at Oxford. Everything in her life seems aligned, until she crosses paths with Jamie. He is charming, intelligent, and, unexpectedly, her poetry professor. Their connection, initially academic, soon blossoms into something deeper, quietly reshaping both of their lives.

The narrative opens with the tone of a cozy romantic comedy. It’s light, it’s sweet, and it promises comfort. Yet, as the plot progresses and dips into heavier territory – fear, loss, and heartbreak – the emotions don’t quite land. The pain feels polished, and the heartbreak, too pristine. This is another cinematic world where characters suffer beautifully but not believably.

Still, the movie holds onto its charm. There’s an old-fashioned tenderness to Anna and Jamie’s dynamic, an endearing kind of nerdy flirtation. The dialogue is deliberate and measured, never tipping into melodrama.

That said, for a story so centred on seizing the moment, few of those moments truly linger. The issue isn’t in the ingredients but in the execution. The central romance feels more like a constructed fantasy than something lived-in. Anna’s dream-come-true tale leans heavily on the classic rich guy, poor girl formula, a trope that feels overused and underexplored here.

Jamie’s family subplot, though touched upon, lacks depth. A deeper dive could’ve added layers to his personal journey.

My Oxford Year (2025)

One bright spot, however, comes in the form of Cecelia, played with nuance by Poppy Gilbert. She cleverly flips a typical supporting role on its head.

In the end, what the film lacks in originality, it makes up for in sentiment. Jamie’s evolution offers more than romance; it’s about choice and embracing transience. This movie may not dazzle, but it does whisper something honest: live fully and love with intention.

Morris directs with steady hands, but Burnett and Osborne’s script falls short of sparks. That left everything for the leads to keep the flame alive.

Star Performance

Carson feels more at home here than in her earlier role in ‘The Life List’ (2025). Yet, she still lacks the spark to fully command the screen. Her performance is competent but not quite compelling.

Mylchreest, on the other hand, shows more promise. His Hugh Grant-like charm hints at untapped potential, especially if given sharper material.

Despite his magical touch, even he can’t lift the film beyond its limits. Still, Carson and Mylchreest remain effortlessly watchable. Their chemistry doesn’t scream for attention; it simmers quietly. Together, they give their characters a subtle weight, steering clear of tired romantic tropes.

Rating and Recommendation

The film hasn't exactly won over critics. On Rotten Tomatoes, only 29% of 17 reviews are positive. The audience is slightly more forgiving, with a 52% Popcornmeter score from over a hundred ratings.

Metacritic echoes the lukewarm response, giving it a 39 out of 100, based on nine reviews. Over on IMDb, it fares a bit better, with a 6.2 from around 3,300 users.

And yet, it's a romantic drama that asks for your patience. For those who still believe in slow-burning love and handwritten letters, this one might just speak to you.

Wrap Up

Netflix original ‘My Oxford Year (2025)’, fronted by Sofia Carson and Corey Mylchreest, blends romance with quiet introspection. The storytelling roots trace back to Allison Burnett, novelist Julia Whelan, and Melissa Osborne. While the narrative feels familiar and lacks real-life emotions, it offers tender moments and restrained charm. Carson and Mylchreest share a grounded, watchable chemistry. Despite its low ratings, the movie may resonate with those drawn to gentle, slow-burning love stories in their mid-20s.

Source Bollywood Hungama